2026-11-17
Once more Will Keyte takes dead-eyed aim at the Courts and Tribunals Bill now "progressing" (if that already politically confounded word can be considered appropriate) through the deliberations of the House of Lords.
"Trial by Jury, Judicium Parium, ... is the embodiment of the Common Law principle that the people judge justice in their own courts and retain for themselves a protection from potential tyranny by refusing to enforce arbitrary punishment upon their fellow man"
"if Trial by Jury has become the safeguard for the people against unjust and overreaching legislation, how can it be logically coherent to claim that it can be removed—by legislation?"
Being Will Keyte, who is extraordinarily well-read on matters constitutional and indeed historical, there is much more that is presented on this topic, but the simple principles that underlie the whole argument are easily comprehensible and in no way at variance with the historical development of Common Law principles.
"Politics turns justice into a zero-sum game: someone gains ‘rights’ at the expense of someone else"
In the process the Rules of Equity get trampled.
But the argument is already too narrow.
"if the government can dictate to a jury ... the laws of evidence ... what evidence is admissible and what inadmissible, and also what force or weight is to be given to the evidence admitted ... it can even require them to convict on any evidence whatever that it pleases to offer them"
In fact, the notion of the word "Jury" has been restricted over the years to those peers of the accused who are responsible solely to determine guilt or innocence. Whereas it should be interpreted to encompass the whole court, judge and jury, operating as an independent body of the accused's peers under no obligation to run any trial except under rules as may seem appropriate to themselves alone.
We begin to understand just how far our current judicial system has been compromised by the very government from which the Jury was supposed to protect us.
The choice ultimately is between the Napoleonic system where everybody submits to the will of the Emperor, and the Common Law system where judgement is acknowledged to be the prerogative of the people themselves.


